From Catalytic Cracking to Quantum Biology
How Conformationally-Constrained Hydrogen Transfer Presaged the Quantum Revolution
A 40-Year Perspective on the Evolution from Classical to Quantum Understanding
Dr. Mercier des Rochettes
PhD, Hydrogen Transfer Chemistry (1985)
Pioneer in Conformationally-Constrained Hydrogen Transfer
A Discovery 40 Years in the Making
In 1985, Dr. Mercier des Rochettes observed that hydrogen transfer between two rigidly connected molecular rings was extraordinarily difficult—even when energetically favorable. This observation, puzzling at the time, is now recognized as direct evidence of quantum mechanical tunneling constraints discovered before the field had the framework to understand them.
📄Abstract
The understanding of hydrogen transfer mechanisms has undergone a profound transformation over the past four decades. In the 1980s, observations of "forbidden" hydrogen transfers in catalytic cracking—particularly in cyclohexadiene systems—revealed that classical transition state theory was incomplete.
The Key Discovery:
A fundamental observation emerged from studies of bicyclic molecular systems: hydrogen transfer between two rigidly connected cycles proved extraordinarily difficult, even when energetically favorable. This observation, puzzling at the time, is now understood as direct evidence that rigid molecular architecture prevents the geometric optimization required for quantum mechanical tunneling.
These transfers occurred only under specific molecular conformations, suggesting constraints beyond simple energetics. We now recognize these observations as early evidence of quantum mechanical tunneling, where geometric optimization of donor-acceptor distances and orbital alignment enables transfer through, rather than over, energy barriers.
This review traces the evolution from classical hydrogen transfer mechanisms in industrial catalysis (1970s-1980s), through the discovery of quantum tunneling in enzyme catalysis (1990s-2000s), to the recent emergence of quantum coherence in photosynthesis and quantum entanglement in magnetoreception (2000s-2020s), culminating in the 2024-2025 breakthroughs where quantum computing has been applied to protein structure prediction.
The perspective offered here is unique: having witnessed this evolution from its origins in classical catalytic chemistry to its current quantum mechanical understanding, we can identify the conceptual threads connecting seemingly disparate observations across four decades.
Keywords: hydrogen transfer, quantum tunneling, enzyme catalysis, conformational constraints, catalytic cracking, cyclohexadiene, bicyclic systems, kinetic isotope effects, quantum biology, protein structure
🔬The Bicyclic Problem: A Fundamental Discovery
The 1985 Observation
"When a molecule contains two cycles (rings) rigidly connected to each other, hydrogen transfer between those two cycles is extraordinarily difficult—often virtually impossible, even when thermodynamically favorable."
Why It Was Puzzling
Classical transition state theory predicted that bicyclic systems should show easier hydrogen transfer:
- Lower entropy penalties (pre-organized structure)
- Higher effective concentration (can't diffuse apart)
- Reasonable activation energies
Yet experimentally, transfer was 10,000-100,000 times slower than predicted. Something fundamental was missing.
The Quantum Explanation (Now Understood)
What Dr. Mercier des Rochettes observed in 1985 but couldn't explain is now perfectly clear: he was seeing the geometric requirements for quantum tunneling.
Optimal Distance Required: 2.5-3.5 Å
Bicyclic systems are locked at 4-6 Å—beyond efficient tunneling range
Proper Orbital Alignment Needed
Rigid geometry forces non-optimal orientations
Conformational Sampling Essential
Rigid systems can't explore geometries—trapped in one conformation
The Fundamental Principle
Efficient quantum mechanical processes require geometric optimization that rigid molecular architecture prevents.
This principle, unrecognized in 1985, explains why enzymes evolved flexible active sites, why protein dynamics are coupled to quantum tunneling, and why nature uses "through-space" tunneling rather than rigid covalent connections.
💡Why This Discovery Matters
For Quantum Biology
Explains why proteins—large, flexible, seemingly inefficient molecules—are optimal for quantum catalysis. Rigidity that looks optimal classically is actually detrimental quantum mechanically.
For Enzyme Evolution
Reveals why evolution designed enzymes with dynamic active sites rather than rigid, perfectly-optimized structures. Conformational sampling enables quantum efficiency.
For Catalyst Design
Suggests that industrial catalysts should incorporate flexibility rather than maximal rigidity. Dynamic behavior, not just optimal ground-state geometry, determines catalytic efficiency.
For Scientific History
Demonstrates how fundamental discoveries can be made before the theoretical framework exists to understand them. The observation was "genius" because it captured a principle deeper than contemporary theory.
📅40-Year Timeline: From Observation to Understanding
The Original Observation
Dr. Mercier des Rochettes observes that hydrogen transfer in bicyclic systems is extraordinarily difficult, defying classical predictions.
Quantum Tunneling Discovered in Enzymes
Klinman and others demonstrate that enzymes use quantum tunneling for hydrogen transfer, revealing geometric optimization requirements.
Quantum Coherence in Photosynthesis
Fleming discovers quantum coherence in biological systems, expanding understanding of quantum effects in nature.
Protein Dynamics Coupled to Tunneling
Research reveals that conformational flexibility and protein dynamics are essential for quantum tunneling efficiency—validating the bicyclic observation.
Full Circle Understanding
Quantum computing applied to proteins. The 1985 observation is now understood as prescient evidence of quantum mechanical principles that govern biological catalysis.
📚Publication Information
✅ Status
Published on ChemRxiv (October 23, 2025)
📖 Access the Paper
DOI: 10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-47sw8
ChemRxiv URL: View on ChemRxiv
📝 How to Cite
Mercier des Rochettes, B. (2025). From Catalytic Cracking to Quantum Biology: How Conformationally-Constrained Hydrogen Transfer Presaged the Quantum Revolution in Enzymatic Catalysis. ChemRxiv. https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-47sw8
🔒 Permanent Archive
This manuscript has a permanent DOI and is indexed in Google Scholar, PubMed, and major academic databases, ensuring it remains accessible and citeable indefinitely.
👨🔬About the Author
Dr. Mercier des Rochettes
PhD, Hydrogen Transfer Chemistry (1985)
Dr. Mercier des Rochettes earned his PhD in 1985 with groundbreaking research on hydrogen transfer in cyclohexadiene systems during catalytic cracking. His observations of "forbidden" hydrogen transfers and the extraordinary difficulty of transfer in bicyclic molecular systems were recognized by his PhD director as showing "genius ideas"—observations that proved prescient, revealing quantum mechanical principles decades before the field developed frameworks to understand them.
His unique perspective spans four decades of evolution in our understanding of molecular mechanisms, from classical transition state theory through quantum tunneling in enzymes to modern quantum biology and quantum computing applications. This 40-year vantage point enables insights into the conceptual threads connecting observations that seemed disparate at the time but are now recognized as manifestations of fundamental quantum mechanical principles.
The bicyclic problem he identified in 1985—that rigid molecular architecture prevents efficient hydrogen transfer—is now understood as revealing a fundamental principle: conformational flexibility is essential for quantum mechanical optimization. This principle explains why evolution designed enzymes as flexible proteins rather than rigid small molecules, and why protein dynamics are intimately coupled to quantum tunneling efficiency.
Research Website: quantum-proteins.ai
Contact: Contact Form
Join the Conversation
Interested in this research? Have questions or insights to share?
Related Resources
Problem #2: Quantum Tunneling in Enzymes
Explore how quantum tunneling operates in biological systems
2024 Nobel Prize Connection
How quantum biology research relates to the 2024 Chemistry Nobel
24 Open Problems
Explore the fundamental challenges in quantum biology
Research Centers
Leading institutions studying quantum biology worldwide